A. PREPARING FOR THE EVALUATION INTERVIEW
1. Year Round
a. Mutually set standards of performance.
b. Regularly praise and coach performance.
c. Periodically review and document performance.
2. Review Facts
a. Review the employee’s classification specifications.
b. Review the employee’s performance based on the job
responsibilities and standards of performance set up at the
beginning of the evaluation period.
c. Review documentation.
d. Consider what you would want to know if you were the employee,
i.e., rating, opportunities, policies, performance, etc.
3. Plan the Content of the Interview
a. Review the past, analyze the present, plan the future.
b. Discuss the year’s accomplishments. Have specific
facts and examples to explain your viewpoint.
c. Discuss what development is needed.
d. Review what the employee might do to get better results.
e. Plan for next year.
f. Determine overall rating.
4. Consider Employee Needs
a. Consider how to stimulate the employee’s efforts to
support department goals.
b. Plan to help the employee understand where development is
needed, if any.
c. Plan to help the employee identify specific steps for development.
d. Plan to let the employee know how effectively he/she is
performing the duties of the position.
5. Schedule Meeting
a. Schedule the meeting and allow sufficient time.
b. Arrange for a suitable meeting place, one which allows for
you to meet away from other employees.
c. Encourage the employee to prepare for the meeting.
B. PERFORMANCE EVALUATION INTERVIEW
1. State the purpose of the discussion and ensure it is clear
to the employee.
a. Stress the importance of performance management.
2. Put the employee at ease by establishing a comfortable, cooperative
climate.
a. Compare your perceptions with those of the employee. Back
it up with facts.
b. Encourage the employee to express his/her opinions.
c. Gain commitment for specific improvement actions.
3. Evaluate the employee’s performance against the established
standards of performance using specific examples of job behaviors
and results.
a. Evaluate the performance, not the person.
b. Avoid personality judgements.
c. Be specific when giving examples of job performance.
4. Involve the employee by asking for and listening to their
input.
a. Ask the employee to review his/her performance.
b. Avoid arguments.
5. Offer your encouragement and support to the employee.
6. Plan for the next evaluation period.
a. Decide on an employee development/training plan.
b. Start the performance management cycle over again with setting
goals and standards.
7. Closing the meeting
a. Summarize what has been discussed and agreed upon.
b. Give the employee a chance to react, question and add additional
ideas and suggestions.
c. Express appreciation for the employee’s participation
and reinforce the commitment to future plans.
C. FOLLOW-UP TO THE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION
1. Provide the employee with a copy of the performance evaluation,
and any work plan developed.
2. Provide the employee a copy of any objectives and standards
set for the upcoming year.
3. Forward the completed evaluation to the division and department
head for review and signatures.
4. A signed copy of the performance evaluation must be submitted
to the Department of Employee Services for inclusion in the employee’s
personnel file.